Reviews

When I grow up by Andrew Daddo

cover image

Ill. by Jonathan Bentley. ABC Kids, 2016. ISBN 9780733333422
(Age: 3-6) Recommended. A young teacher poses this question to her class: 'what do you want to be when you grow up?' Their creative answers will delight and surprise you. Standing on a student chair at the front of the class, each child states their goal, their future dreams. Little Miss Goldy Locks asks the class to imagine the buns, braids, bobs and beehives she will create. 'So much hair, so many stories.' What about an inventor - a invention to clean a bedroom, clear the table, stack and unstack the dishwasher? Floating in space, the astronaut will see the stars, she will photograph new worlds and meet strange aliens.
Daddo writes expressively; he uses alliteration, imaginative descriptions and rhyming text. He also presents strong female role models, no stereotypes - the princess can rescue herself, thank you! The last little girl has a wildly creative list and ends with a special message, she just wants to be herself.
Jonathan Bentley's mixed-media images are lively, and bring Daddo's story to life. As each student shares their future dreams, the colourful illustrations show the astronaut swept into space in a fiery whizz-bang rocketship and into a fantasy adventure with green goblins and magical wizards.
Andrew Daddo's When I grow up is a delightful story to share with a family. This entertaining and enjoyable picture book is suitable for engaging young learners in thinking about their future careers, creating artworks or a class big book.
Rhyllis Bignell

Once upon a dream by Liz Braswell

cover image

A twisted tale bk 2. Disney, 2016. ISBN 9781484707258
(Age: 12+) A twisted tale series written by Liz Braswell explores the idea that 'a key turning point in Disney movie didn't work out as planned.' These dark stories are suited to a young adult audience as they explore themes of revenge, the forces of evil, greed and the misuse of power.
In Once upon a dream, the story questions what would happen if Sleeping Beauty did not wake up. When Prince Phillip falls asleep as he kisses Aurora, this fairy tale's crowded plot takes a radical turn. The mind of the princess is controlled by a bad fairy's curse and Aurora has to escape from a different thorny castle and travel through a dangerous magical kingdom created from her dreams. Together with the prince, she traverses the land, with Maleficent's spies following them. The three good fairies are now evil, Aurora's parents are unkind, and they greedily rule their kingdom, eliminating the good witches and fairies. Maleficent is portrayed in a very different light as well.
Written in the third person, Liz Braswell has changed a significant amount of the story, switching roles for so many of the familiar characters. At times, the plot is difficult to follow because of all the changes. Her graphic, descriptive writing style includes scenes of death and violence. In the background, the pages are smudged with ink to heighten the dark feel of the story. Once upon a dream is definitely written for fans of this genre.
Rhyllis Bignell

The Beast within: A tale of Beauty's prince by Serena Valentino

cover image

Disney Paper Rocket, 2016. ISBN 9781474840828
(Age: 9+) This novel presents a very different point of view to the Disney movie Beauty and the Beast, Belle is a minor player and the central characters are the Prince and Gaston who begin as childhood best friends.
Valentino begins with the Beast reminiscing about the curse that places him in his enchanted castle, disfigured and alone. In his teenage years, he became vain and bigheaded, even with his best friend and hunting companion Gaston. The Prince's fiancee, beautiful Circe, is really the daughter of a pig farmer, therefore she is rejected. Circe is actually the youngest sister of three witches and she reaps her revenge by cursing him, and he must find true love by his twenty-first birthday or remain a beast forever.
The Prince searches for a bride selecting Princess Tulip Morningstar as the perfect candidate. Here the story deviates greatly from the original, he treats her cruelly, belittling her, happy that she does not read and thinks only of himself. Some of this is difficult to engage in, the more astute reader may be confronted by the Prince's actions, when he sends her off in disgrace with a promised dowry.
The cruel witches, Lucinda, Martha and Ruby, send Circe off to help poor Princess Tulip who had jumped off a cliff into the sea, deeply hurt by the Prince's rejection. Ursula the sea witch had taken Tulip's beauty and voice, leaving the poor princess to live a life of ugliness and muteness. The story switches back to Belle finally and her hurried escape from the castle. The evil witches summon wolves to chase her and 'scratch, bite her until she bleeds and kill her.' As the story ends, Valentino returns to the original plot, Gaston hunting the Beast and Belle's tender kiss breaking the curse.
This twisted fairy tale reads as fan fiction, overly dramatic and descriptive, dark and macabre, with the Prince's sexist comments and attitude distasteful.
Rhyllis Bignell

Tales from the Shadowhunter Academy by Cassandra Clare and others

cover image

Tales from the Shadowhunter Academy bks.1-10. Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406362848
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Fans of Cassandra Clare's series will be delighted with this compilation of ten illustrated stories previously published individually as e-books. The stories by Clare, Sarah Rees Brennan, Maureen Johnson and Robin Wasserman follow the adventures of Simon Lewis, star of The Mortal Instruments, as he trains at the Shadowhunter Academy. Simon doesn't know who he is anymore as he has lost most of his memories so he decides to train really hard to become a Shadowhunter, hoping that he will regain his identity as he goes.
This compilation is very clever and engrossing. People who have read all the books will gain insights into the backgrounds and what has happened to different characters as Simon progresses through his training. I was particularly interested to read about Tessa Gray and what happens to her as an adult, revealed in one of the stories when she is a guest lecturer at the academy. Other characters appear, like Jace Herondale and Magnus Blane, but each story grows on the back of the previous one, and the reader gets to know and sympathise with Simon as he struggles with his memories of Isabelle, his feelings of worth and his friendships at the Academy. It makes for a complete view of the Academy and what is involved in training to become a Shadowhunter.
Some big themes are touched on - class and privilege, stereotypes and duty of care, all done in an engrossing way, with Simon having to make some difficult decisions about who he is and where he belongs. Each story is illustrated at the beginning, with graphic novel type of illustrations, which are interesting to peruse.
For readers who are not familiar with the Mortal Instruments, Infernal Devices, and Dark Artifices series, there is enough in the stories to ensure that they will pick up the series, just to find out what has happened in the past and readers familiar with the books will be eagerly awaiting the upcoming Last Hours series. Readers may also want to go on and read other books by Brennan, Johns and Wasserman.
Pat Pledger

Malkin Moonlight by Emma Cox

cover image

Ill. by Rohan Eason. Bloomsbury, 2016. ISBN 9781408870846
(Age: 9+) Recommended. Emma Cox's Malkin Moonlight won the 2015 New Children's Author Prize for the National Literacy Trust. Cox delves deeply into the cat's world, and she creates a believable society, where cats can communicate, read, marry and support each other. Similar to Watership Down and Guardians of the Ga'Hoole, we follow the path of a young kitten as he grows into cathood, learns life lessons and ventures far from home.
Black cat, Malkin Moonlight is the narrator of this carefully crafted tale, his story begins with a narrow escape from an unkind owner. As a kitten, Malkin talks to the Moon who recognises his special traits and marks him with a beautiful white collar. The Moon's advice guides his path, and influences the life choices he makes. He is a kind, brave feline who will make sacrifices for his friends and use his skills to be a peacemaker.
Malkin's friendship with a beautiful domestic kitten Roux is mutually rewarding, she teaches him to read and he encourages her to venture further from her home, to experience the feel of sand on her paws and the salty sea spray. Malkin's sixth sense assists him in protecting a swan's eggs from a hungry vole and leads him to rescue the father swan trapped in netting.
On the night of the Blue Moon Malkin and Roux are married, but happiness turns to sadness when Roux's owners sell their home and pub and move across town. A month later, the cats meet again on the seawall and Horatio the seagull guides them to their new home the Recycling Centre. Here amidst the sections of Newspapers and Aluminium and Tin Cans, they settle in to life with the friendly cats that sleep on the mattresses, read the papers and play amongst the recycled goods.
On the other side of the wall in the toxic wasteland live the Putrescibles, evil cats with scarred bodies who eke out their existence in a dirty disgusting environment. They fight the cats of the Recycling Plant carrying on a deep-seated feud. Malkin's rescue of a Putrescible kitten, Calica is the turning point. As the wasteland is cleaned up and the rubbish removed, Malkin brings both groups of cats together to live in the safety of the Recycling Plant.
Emma Cox explores a range of themes including caring for the environment, sustaining animal life, the impact of pollutants on the land and waterways. Malkin Moonlight celebrates the power of love, being courageous, facing your fears and living life to the fullest. Rohan Eason's line drawings add drama and liveliness to the story. This is a wonderfully written text, full of descriptive imagery and well-developed characters perfect for a Middle Primary class novel.
Rhyllis Bignell.

Clash of the worlds by Chris Columbus, Ned Vizzini, Chris Rylander

cover image

House of Secrets series. HarperCollins, 2016. ISBN 9780007465859
(Age: 9+) Clash of the Worlds concludes the action-packed adventure House of Secrets trilogy. Chris Rylander co-authored this final novel with Chris Columbus after the death of Ned Vizzini in 2013.
The Walker children are once again in the midst of a difficult situation; their father's gambling addiction has led to the selling of their mansion and their subsequent return to their previous small apartment. Eleanor and Cordelia sneak out in the dark of night; spend all their birthday money on raw meat to feed their friend Fat Jagger, a huge colossus who has escaped from his book into their world. Unfortunately, other book characters have also crossed over and it is up to the Walkers to remedy the situation. Brendan's attempt to raise Denver Kristoff the author of the book worlds has released a Zombie Apocalypse.
Of course, Brendan, Cordelia and Eleanor must return to the story worlds to right the wrongs and pursue the three Wordkeeper objects needed for permanently sealing off the fantasy world from the real one and rescuing Fat Jagger. The evil Wind Witch needs to be stopped, before she leads her army into San Francisco.
For the best outcome, the three Walkers need to split up, each paired with a book character. They race through Western world, the science fiction and fantasy books, to Atlantis, endure epic battles, frightening life and death situations, with the action continually switching focus. Unbelievable events occur; Cordelia and Adie's dramatically escape from the blue whale, Brendan encounters animated mummies, dealing with duplicate treasure maps and aliens and Eleanor needs rescuing from Castle Corroway.
The authors have written a nonstop action, fantasy adventure suited to fans from 9 years, as their offsiders pay a high price for assisting the Walkers.
Rhyllis Bignell

Frozen heart by Elizabeth Rudnick

cover image

Frozen Heart series. Disney Paper Rocket, 2016. ISBN 9781484730515
(Ages: 9+) Fans of Frozen the Disney movie released in 2013 will recognise a large amount of the similarities to the film's dialogue included in this new novel written by Elizabeth Rudnick. There is a definite fan-fiction element to the writing, as the stories of Anna and Hans are developed instead of Elsa's and Kristoff's. Each chapter alternates as the characters narrate their stories. Young Anna is confused and concerned by the imprisonment of her sister Anna, after the incident when she magically filled the ballroom with snow. We are introduced to Prince Hans' background; he is the thirteenth and youngest son of King of the Southern Isles, bullied by his older brothers. He works his way into being the king's favourite, with the goal of attending the coronation of Princess Elsa and marrying her.
When Anna meets Hans at the coronation, there is an instant attraction and she desperately wants to say yes to his proposal. Of course, when she asks for her sister's permission, Anna becomes angry; she creates an everlasting winter in Arendelle and then flees into the mountains.
Elizabeth Rudnick's action and adventure novel explores the motivations of Elsa and Hans, what drives them to act in certain ways. With the themes of love, sacrifice, greed, selfishness and the fight of good and evil, Frozen Heart is suited to a preteen audience who grew up with the movie.
Rhyllis Bignell

And I darken by Kiersten White

cover image

Penguin, 2016. ISBN 9780552573740
(Age: 13+) Highly recommended. Genres: Historical Fiction, Romance, Action. You become absolutely consumed in the world of Ladislav (Lada) and Radu Dragwla as you venture with them on their journey throughout the Ottoman empire. And I Darken, the first book in a 3 book saga, is a story about Vlad the Impaler, a ruthless Romanian prince - as a woman. The book also follows the journey of an alternate personality, her brother, struggling to overcome the ruthlessness of the 1400's. The book carries the reader through their early years, birthed as the children of the 'dragon', as they grow and become young adults.
Lada, becoming victim of the social norms of women at the time, grows to overcome expectations and rises to conquer. Whereas Radu, gifted with the tools to achieve an easy life, learns how hard it is to live up to expectations when he struggles to understand the brutality of their father. The well crafted story branches from here, allowing the reader to grasp what it was like in this time, as they face many challenges and deal with life-rendering experiences.
The book was thoroughly enjoyable. The writing style easy and understandable, captures the audience with fluent imagery and enlightenment. Despite the substantial difference in time and context, the remarkable character development allows the reader to understand the characters' motivations in order to experience this journey WITH them. The theme of the book carries a dark tone, incorporating the reader in the book itself, but also on the emotional ride of countless ups and downs.
Overall, the riveting tale of Lada and Radu, the two characters at the core of this story, is an original story and one not to be overlooked. I am eagerly awaiting for the 2nd book to be released.
Ethan Russell (Student)

My Lady Jane - the not entirely true story by C. Hand, B. Ashton and J. Meadows

cover image

Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406372021
(Age: 11+) Highly recommended. Lady Jane Grey was Queen of Tudor England for only 9 days. That much is true to history. But this Jane is a very reluctant Queen, married off to Gifford Dudley in the days leading up to King Edward VI's 'death' in suspicious circumstances.
A collaboration of three authors, the Lady Janies, have created a humorous alternate version of English history. In addition to twisting events, the authors add a pinch of magic and frequently breach the fourth wall. Jane, Edward's heir and favourite cousin, is a scholar and intrigued rather than disappointed that her new prince consort is unable to stop turning into a horse each night.
You see, Jane's magical England consists of Verities (regular people) and shape-shifting people called E∂ians. Not all E∂ians realize they possess the ability, so the inevitable nudity after returning to human form is a hoot.
When Edward's mad sister Mary deposes Jane, she immediately decrees the genocide of all E∂ians. In the pursuit of both love and revenge, Edward, Jane, Gifford, Bess and their trusted servants problem-solve their way out of some sticky situations in order to regain the throne.
This flirtatious fantasy romp through ye olde England is an easy read not to be dismissed. Hopefully we can look forward to a whole series penned by the three collaborators: Cynthia Hand, Brodi Ashton and Jodi Meadows because as Napoleon Bonaparte once proffered, 'What else is history but a fable agreed upon?'
Deborah Robins

Survivors by David Long

cover image

Faber and Faber, 2016. ISBN 9780571316014
(Age: 9+) Highly recommended. Survivors is a gorgeous hardback book, offering a collection of survival stories. Readers can read about known characters such as Shackleton and Mawson as well as less known characters such as Juliane Koepcke who fell from a plane. Each story averages 8 pages in length and because each chapter is a stand-alone event, readers can read them in any order and over any time frame. The stories of Mawson and Shackleton link well to Year 4 and Year 6 Science and the story of Greg Rasmussen surviving the Kalahari Desert is also a good link for these year levels with the study of Africa and harsh environments. The book would also be great for reading aloud in a classroom. Teachers could read a story a week, investigate story sequences, created storyboards, investigate the vocabulary and study the characters and how they survived. The short stories are great for comparing events and characters. The language in each chapter is descriptive and easy to read, making this book ideal for and highly recommended for readers aged 9+.
Kylie Kempster

Lisette's Paris notebook by Catherine Bateson

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2017. ISBN 9781760293635
(Age: 14+) Highly recommended. Paris. Romance. Art. Fashion. When eighteen year old Lisette hits Paris for the summer holidays before going to uni in Melbourne, she is aware that she is doing something her mother always dreamed of doing. Mum has arranged that she stay with Madame Christophe, a clairvoyant she met online and Lisette will take French lessons to improve her language skills as well as gain an appreciation of the arts and fashion, touring art galleries and haute couture. From the start the reader is aware of some tension between Lisette and her mother who raised her after her artist lover abandoned her and fled to Wales.
With misgivings Lisette goes along to French lessons in her vintage punk and Doc Martins, only to be challenged by much she sees and hears.
Her great-grandmother was the proud owner of a Chanel jacket and with a seamstress mother, fashion is part of her makeup.
But she does not reckon with the men she meets and readers will laugh out loud as I did, when Lisette consents to being a model for one of the art students at her French class, and then has a worrying time trying to work out what to wear to disrobe.
But try as she might, this man is not for her and accidentally meeting an Englishman in the park, begins to fall in love.
This funny, absorbing coming of age novel, full of references to Paris, fashion, art galleries and food will fascinate teenage girls yearning like Lisette to try all that Paris offers.
Paris invades every page: its sights and sounds, colours, fashion, architecture and people are the thread of the novel, making every reader want to go and capture the essence of the city, while those who have been will wish to return.
Lisette has some real choices to make, but is always aware of her return ticket to Australia and the looming departure date. Finding that her dead father left her money, allows her to make a decision that had been impossible and in ringing his widow, finds common ground with the woman she has never met. Middle secondary girls will love Lisette, seeing Paris through her eyes, looking at her options as she becomes more involved with Hugo who must return to England. Bateson has again produced a wonderfully entertaining story of a young girl in an unfamiliar situation, potent with choices, impelling the readers to ponder what choice they would make.
Lisette is surrounded by beautifully written characters that will endear the reader to Lisette and her friends. Hugo is an enigma but adorable, Madam Christophe magnificent with her tarot cards and scarves, Fabienne stunning with her stilettos, Anders and Gabi ooze early warning signals, while the girls Lisette meets give her courage. All of her experiences encourage her to take her own path, to find her own way, to be herself. And she does.
Fran Knight

Girl detached by Manuela Salvi

cover image

Barrington Stoke, 2016. ISBN 9781911370024
(Age: 15+) Recommended. Sexual content. Fiction. Romance. Tragedy. Teenage. The book, Girl detached, falls under the umbrella of romance and tragedy. Aleksandra (Alek) is a teenage girl with a bad stutter. Living under the roof of her grandmother after her mother abandoned her at a young age, Alek became a victim of her Grandmother's strict discipline and protection in order to avoid making the mistakes her mother made. The book details her story after her grandmother's sudden death, when Alek is forced to move yet again, back to where her life started. Living with her mother, stepfather and half-brother, she struggles to find ground in her new 'home'.
Although this book employs some very overused themes such as romance and tragedy, it also stands out on its own. The author's brave actions bring light to very real and serious themes that exist for the target audience and is nothing short of commendable.
Although the book is difficult to get into and consists of raw content, it becomes easier to read throughout the duration of the book. The writing style is concise and vivid, allowing the reader to become easily drawn into the reality of each scene. As a result of this, the themes and the unfolding story resonate on a deeper level.
The book is a cautionary tale for members of the 'love is blind' club. The morally questionable and often wrongfully considered actions of the characters, highlights what happens as a result of certain privileges being granted to young adults.
Overall, the raw components and educational value of the book is what won it for me. The consistent character development and the brutal ending also tied this book up perfectly.
Ethan Russell (Student)

The complete adventures of Figaro and Rumba by Anna Fienberg

cover image

Ill. by Stephen Michael King. Allen & Unwin, 2017. ISBN 9781760292997
(Age: 5-8) Recommended. Early chapter book. Humour. Friendship. Adventure. With two Figaro and Rumba stories in one book, newly independent readers will thrill to the adventures of these two friends.
In the first story, 'Figaro and Rumba and the crocodile cafe', good friends Figaro the dog and Rumba the cat plan to catch the Very Fast Train to the beach. But their friend, Rat, has lost his friend, Nate, and so an adventure begins.
King's wry illustrations set the scene perfectly, adding a level of humour and anticipation which readers will adore.
This six chapter book will enthrall and delight as they read of this wonderful pair of characters and their friends. Chapter four sees them on the train at long last, but in the carriage of a very shady character, a crocodile. With his easy charm and wonderful waistcoat, he invites them to his cafe, redolent of Cuba where Rumba was born. Figaro, with some suspicion of the crocodile decides not to stay, but goes off to explore. He finds cats locked in a small shed and ringing the police, learns that the crocodile is a cat-napper, ready to add Rumba to his captives.
A lovely story, neatly resolved, it is full of things to take note of: invitations from strangers, friendship, holidays with friends on a train, learning to swim and taking risks for a friend while learning a little about Cuba and the Spanish language. But the main thing is the story of friends helping each other, and along with the lively illustrations, will be sought after.
The second story, 'Figaro and Rumba and the cool cats' sees Figaro singing along with the Cool Cats at their rehearsal. The cats are those rescued from the crocodile's cages in the first of the two stories. The lead singer cannot cope with Fig's howling and barking, even if he does so very quietly. Rolando the cleaner, a small sloth also found in the cage, listens halfheartedly to Fig's complaints.
But another friend has the keys to the singers' Catmobile, and with Fig convinced he has seen a monster in the car, they go off on another adventure.
Both stories have a wide appeal to readers newly attempting chapter books for themselves and with stories like these, will be most satisfied.
Fran Knight

Diary of a 6th grade Ninja by Marcus Emerson

cover image

Allen and Unwin, 2017 ISBN 9781760295554
(Age: 9+) Recommended. School. Martial arts. Chase talks directly to the reader, enfolding them into his world of being a Ninja. Eleven year old Chase has an unromantic view of himself, scrawny, unpopular, not good at sports, a reader, but when his parents move into a slightly bigger house, he must go to a new school, Buchanan, and here things change. The only person he knows is his cousin, Zoe, but he is unsure about how he will fit in. She takes him under her wing, showing him around and introducing him to her friends, but when he sees something flash by his eyes in the woods near the school, she fends him off. But he is intrigued and going into the woods finds a Ninja clan, willing to allow him into their fold after he has passed the test. Zoe joins him, but when they are asked to do one more test, Zoe balks, walking away. Brayden warns Chase about joining the group but Chase is unconcerned, even if it means lying. But when the group gives him Zoe's backpack to return to the school, and he finds it full of money, the cash missing form the school money drive, he is torn thinking about what to do.
Friendship and loyalty drive this story as Chase must work out just who his friends are, and whether lying and stealing to be with the Ninjas is worth it.
The story about choices will appeal to the target audience. Easy to read, with chapters of three or four pages, and some illustrations to break up the print, the series of ten books will be sought after.
Fran Knight

Stone cold by Jane Yolen and Adam Stemple

cover image

Ill. by Orion Zangara. The Stoneman mysteries bk 1. Graphic Universe, 2016. ISBN 9781512411553
Graphic Novel. Murder mystery. Dark fantasy. Set in Edinburgh in the 1930s this very dark graphic tale begins with a murder and suicide rescue, and a talking Gargoyle on a local church, and some priests who seem to have issues with one another. The young lad whose life is saved goes on to join the investigative work of the gargoyle - a beast trapped in stone. With frightening progression, murder becomes common and involves evil influences in the oppressive and gloomy streets. The young lad's work is to collect information in order to solve the mystery of who is responsible for the loss of life. But is he being dragged into the evil net of the dark forces?
This is no light-hearted comic book! Rather it is a dark and ominous fantasy that involves evil spiritual influences, but tangles this with traditional faith contexts. Not something to recommend to a young vulnerable reader. The black and white illustrations in graphic novel panels are atmospheric, but it isn't always easy to recognise or identify the characters speaking. Although the graphic novel genre does cater for the dark story-lines of Noir fantasy, this didn't appeal to me.
Carolyn Hull