Reviews

Wish you were here by Michelle Blackbird

cover image

Vanguard Press, 2018. ISBN 9781784654320
(Age: 14 +) Highly recommended. Genre: Historical fiction, WW 2. This is the story of two girls in the Netherlands caught up in World War 2 and the German occupation. Michaela's story starts at the end of the war. She begins her new life after being in hiding and faces the challenges of freedom, school, and friendships. She struggles in trying to understand about what really happened during the holocaust as she begins her new life in freedom.
Hannie and her family were captured during the war and sent to a concentration camp. Her story is touched on briefly as she faces the horrors of the time. This is very challenging to the reader, and we can feel the despair of Hannie and her family.
Two girls, two different pathways during the same war. This compelling story not only gives you an understanding of the time but shows us the strength the girls needed in facing the challenges ahead of them.
I enjoyed this very moving story and readers who have loved the "Diary of Anne Frank" will find this a must read.
Links with "Diary of Anne Frank"
Rating 9/10
Debra Pepper

Losing the Girl by Marinaomi

cover image

Life on Earth Book 1. Graphic Universe, 2018. ISBN 9781512449105
(Age: older teens) Themes: Graphic novel, Relationships, pregnancy, friendship. Part one introduces us to Nigel Jones, a likeable skateboarding boy living with his mum, dealing with his parents' separation while trying to find a girlfriend. The graphic style is simple and expressive, particularly Nigel's hair. Small details like action indicators, unusual perspectives and individual text types add depth and interest. Nigel asks Emily for a date and she asks him if there is a serious side to his joking around. They quickly get closer and he asks her if she is a virgin. They discover they are both virgins and kiss. Part two is from Emily's perspective. She confesses to her friend Paula that she wants to lose her virginity to someone more memorable, like older boy Brett Hathaway. The strong black and white graphic style comes into its own at a party where Emily's increasing emotional instability under the influence of alcohol and Brett Hathaway is effectively expressed in how she is drawn. She does lose her virginity and becomes pregnant. Older sisters and friends help clarify her options but the emotional roller coaster is vividly expressed. As the abortion approached Emily retreats more and more into herself until she is a brief outline. Friendships are tested and some harsh lessons are learnt. Part three is from Brett Hathaway's point of view. Secretly in love with Joanna who wants to be just friends he learns about Emily's abortion and goes to see her. The softer grey washes are expressive, but not as engaging as the previous styles. The Fourth section is from Paula Navarro's perspective. Emily's not so attractive friend, draws her own narrative in her own sketchy style. Scarred by her own abusive relationship with Darren, she is unable to support Emily as she too is attracted to Brett and her story is infused with guilt and jealousy. The end is complex, incorporating colour for the first time and returning to a thread about a missing student who may have been abducted by aliens! "Losing the Girl" is a complex interweaving of perspectives on the lives of ordinary suburban teens told through their own relatable voices. We are led to feel their awkward moments and mundane concerns interleaved with life changing decisions in a sophisticated graphic presentation. Teens will find this appealing though the sex and one incident of smoking drugs might preclude younger readers. It will have wider appeal than graphic novel fans, especially readers from non-English speaking backgrounds and less literate students.
Sue Speck

Being a princess is very hard work by Sarah KilBride

cover image

Ill. by Ada Grey. Bloomsbury Publishing, 2018. ISBN 9781408881941
(Age: All ages) Highly recommended. Themes: Self Esteem, Rhyming book. If you ever thought being a REAL Princess was loads of fun, and even easy, then this funny rhyming picture book will set you straight. Imagine sitting on a throne for hours, to practising handshakes and waving at your subjects when all you feel like doing is having a nap. Think of having no time to play, keeping all those body noises inside and most definitely no nose picking. Tables manners must be immaculate and no fussy eating allowed. Worse still the dragons you might have to contend with, and the frogs just waiting to be bestowed with a kiss. Having to look neat and spotlessly clean always, which pretty much makes anything remotely fun out of the question. Just being yourself, a REAL little girl, moody, energetic, noisy and yes messy, of course, but also generous and kind is so much better.
That's the opinion (anyway) of one would-be young princess's Mum and Dad, who want their child to know that they love her for who and what she is. The rhyming text is complimented with fabulous illustrations with double spread pictures full of wonderful details, many of them taken from traditional fairy tales, adding another dimension for the reader to enjoy.
Perfect for young would-be princesses and parents that want to get the message to their child to appreciate their "inner beauty" and develop themselves in spite of any "quirky" traits they think they may have.
Donna Isgar

Save the date by Mary Kay Andrews

cover image

St Martin's Press, 2018. ISBN 9781250190291
(Age: Older adolescents - Adult) Plunging us into the frenetic life of the young woman who has chosen to be a wedding florist, whose work begins with flowers and catapults into the full thing - the flowers in the church (and often for the reception too), the flowers carried by the bridal party, the decoration of the reception venue, flowers for the bride and often advice for the bride, or sometimes for the mother-of-the-bride, or even the groom, Mary Kay Andrews sets up a protagonist who keeps up a pace that seems impossible to imagine. This novel would be suitable for older adolescents and indeed for adults intrigued by this particular world in the southern states of the USA.
Cara Kryzik is on the rebound from an unsuccessful relationship, and has started up her own shop to supply the luxurious floral decorations expected for weddings, both commonly at the church and in the wedding venue as decreed by the mores of society in the southern US states. Her brief goes beyond the flowers that might be carried by the bridal party, as she begins to create the decorations, responding to the brides, for the whole ceremony and reception, also advising on many other aspects of the wedding. The costs are high, and not just in monetary terms, as so much is expected by the brides, the mothers of the brides, the attendants and indeed the family, and Kara is under enormous pressure for almost every wedding, pre-wedding and post-wedding celebrations for which she caters. However, the complexity of her life is extended further as she deals with a broken marriage, a new lover, unhelpful workers and a father who wants to run her life.
Fast-paced, like Kara's life, this novel takes us on a journey to the southern United States, exploring the pressures exerted by the families on the brides as well as the weight of the expectation of perfection in every single aspect of the whole ceremony and celebrations on that very special day. However, the underlying story of Kara dominates, and we are drawn deeply into her family troubles, her attempts to leave her old life behind to forge her way into a new life, the dominating father and the element of trust that concerns her deeply in her relationships.
Captivating and fast-paced, this delightful novel depicts southern life so vibrantly, exploring both its expectations of family members in their daily lives, and especially on such occasions as a wedding, Andrews constructs a world, moreover, into which she draws us deeply, exploring this world's complex pressures on young people to meet and marry the right person, to display the family's success in suitable fashion, and to impress the world around them with their events. Its richly evocative atmosphere is the heart of this novel, and is the core of its strength.
This novel would be suitable for adolescent readers, but would also be a captivating story for all ages, particularly those who are interested in the world of the southern United States, or those who have not experienced the particular way of life that is depicted so richly in this novel.
Elizabeth Bondar

Melowy and the song of the moon by Danielle Star

cover image

Scholastic, 2016. ISBN 9781338151763
(Age: 6-10) The Melowies are a select group of winged horses who are born with a hidden symbol on their wings and a magical power. The 4 ancient islands of Aura are the homes of the Melowies. The Melowies must leave their island homes and attend school at the Castle of Destiny.
In this second book of the series, the 5 Melowies will be part of a musical performance at the school.
This book has themes of friendship, self-confidence and jealousy. Selene has to overcome her fear of failure and is supported by her friends to audition for the role of Moon, explaining the title "Melowy and the song of the moon".
These small novels are about 80 pages long and are packed with intensely coloured illustrations. Maps at the beginning of the novel show all the island realms of Aura and each part of the Castle of Destiny. There is also a fact sheet on the 5 Melowies, which helped me distinguish each Melowy when I was reading the story.
The Melowies have the same friendship issues as middle primary aged students and these books have instant appeal with their bright colours and fantasy Pegasus characters.
The Melowies will appeal to students aged 6-10 years old.
Jane Moore

Melowy: Dreams come true by Danielle Star

cover image

Scholastic, 2018. ISBN 9781338151749
(Ages 6-8) Theme: Fantasy. Short and quick to read. Magical Pegasi go to a school for magical horses.
Aura, a 'magical land' that's 'in a distant galaxy' has four Island realms (Winter, Spring, Day and Night) that are populated by Pegasi. Some Pegasi are Melowies, marked with a hidden symbol on their wings that indicate magical abilities. Melowies are summoned to school at the 'Castle of Destiny' in the clouds. Frontmatter details these realms, provides a map of the castle, and provides short profiles on the five main characters.
The story opens on the day the new Melowies arrive - which also happens to be the anniversary of Cleo's arrival day (the day she was found mysteriously at the castle, origins unknown and no melowy mark). The story centres on Cleo and Maya, a shy Pegasus from Spring. During the entrance test, Cleo enters mistakenly, and Maya asks her to stay and help, and she unsurprisingly ends up assisting all the main characters.
The brightly coloured Pegasi have unicorn horns, highly decorative wings, heavy eye make-up, and long flowing manes. There is not a hint of subtlety about them. The epilogue's twist foreshadows a threat to Aura.
Donna Isgar

Cicada by Shaun Tan

cover image

Hachette, 2018. ISBN 9780734418630
(Age: all) Highly recommended. Themes: Cicadas, Employment, Workplace, Bullying, Difference. Unappreciated, Cicada works in a bleak office in a very tall building. He has worked there for seventeen years without a break. He never makes mistakes, yet his co workers taunt and bully him because he is different. His request for a promotion is turned down, because he is not human. He is not allowed in the staff rest rooms. He stays late to finish his work, yet no one thanks him. When he retires he is told to clean his desk. He has no home, no money and no place to be. He climbs to the top of the building, desolate and ready to say goodbye. But here something wonderful happens and Cicada is able to show all humans that he is made of better stuff and does not have to spend his life in the office building, but can fly off to greener pastures.
This scintillating story, full of hope and promise that will appeal to all those who read it. It is multi-layered, at once ruminating on the drudgery of modern work, of bullying in the workplace, of prejudice against those who look different, with hints about homelessness and hopelessness but also of looking forward and of optimism, as Cicada breaks out, paralleling the fact that cicadas can live underground for up to seventeen years before emerging.
Tan's rich oil paintings reflect the muted colours of the dreary work space, with Cicada's bright green just poking above his partition.
Hints of Escher and Edward Hopper amongst others, can be spotted within the pages, while the poem quoted on the publications page adds another layer of meaning and interest to the story.
"Calm and serene
the sound of a cicada permeates the rock"
and Tan's clipped words reflect a minimalism which is deafening in what it leaves out, each small stanza ending with "Tok Tok Tok"!
Each offering from Shaun Tan is breathtaking in its originality.
Fran Knight

The Storm Keeper's Island by Catherine Doyle

cover image

Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408896884
(Age: 9+) Recommended. "When Fionn Boyle sets foot on Arranmore Island, it begins to stir beneath his feet . . . Once in a generation, Arranmore Island chooses a new Storm Keeper to wield its power and keep its magic safe from enemies. The time has come for Fionn's grandfather, a secretive and eccentric old man, to step down. Soon, a new Keeper will rise. But, deep underground, someone has been waiting for Fionn. As the battle to become the island's next champion rages, a more sinister magic is waking up, intent on rekindling an ancient war." (Publisher)
This will certainly be one that does not gather dust on the shelf. It is a gorgeous read full of adventure with magic interwoven throughout the story-line. It is also packed with a range of emotions allowing you to go on a true roller coaster ride. The relationship between Fionn, his grandfather and father supports this. Fionn is a powerful character who immediately connects with the reader and Arranmore Island is a place we all yearn to visit. It is certainly a clever author that can write a book that will appeal to the younger reader and also an adult audience. I would recommend the book for readers 9 and up and for both girls and boys. It fits into fantasy, adventure, family and a touch of mystery. I believe this is part of a trilogy and I am sure many children will be left hanging and waiting for the release of the second book. A must have for the collection.
Kathryn Schumacher

Truthers by Geoffrey Girard

cover image

Carolrhoda Lab, 2017. ISBN 9781512427790
(Age: 16+) Highly recommended. Themes: Conspiracy; Terrorism - 9/11; Truth and Lies; Foster children; Identity; Mental health. Katie's Dad has been forced into a mental institution because he claims to know something about the 9/11 terrorism plot that could imply there was government complicity in what happened. Is he being silenced because he has spoken out? Is his former service in Afghanistan in some way involved? Conspiracy or truth? Is he just a victim of drug use and PTSD because of his former service or does he really know something that would upset the world's perception of what actually happened on 9/11? Katie is plunged into the drama as she tries to find a way to free her war-hero father from this 'imprisonment' that seems to be more than just mental health treatment. Plunged into the "Truthers" world (conspiracy theorists acting within cyberspace and beyond, with hackers working to uncover hidden 'truths'), she becomes twisted and challenged by what is truth for her father and for her own personal history.
This is a brilliantly compelling and slightly disturbing story - but one that you won't want to stop reading. The teenaged characters are intelligent and very likeable (and there are hints of a blossoming romance and 'coming-of-age' drama). The plot is begging to be made into a movie script. This author has delved deeply into the conspiracy world and has revealed the dilemma in the cyber-world of determining truth and of hiding information. And for Katie, there is added mystery about her own existence and identity.
Highly recommended for ages 16 - Adult readers.
Carolyn Hull

Let's go ABC! Things that go, from A to Z by Rhonda Gowler Greene

cover image

Illustrated by Daniel Kirk. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9780802735096
(Age: 3-6) Alphabet. Vehicles. Rhyming book. Each page of this alphabet book contains a short rhyme about a vehicle for each letter of the alphabet, e.g., "I pick up speed. I'm gaining height. I catch the wind, ascend-in flight! I'm an... Airplane!" Each letter is hidden within the illustration or placed somewhere on the vehicle, eg. the L is the seat within the limousine. This feature, along with the large capital alphabet spread on the endpapers, will help children develop a visual understanding of letters. Exclamation marks are everywhere but they do help to add to the energy of the book. Putting the name of the vehicle at the end of the rhyme is clever as it prompts the child to name the vehicle after the predictive cue "I'm a... ". There is a good mix of familiar (bus, motorcycle) and unfamiliar (iceboat, zeppelin) vehicles and features animals as well as some other characters (santa, snowman) beloved by children. There is lots of action within each page and the text reads well at a fast pace, which will keep the young listener engaged. This is noticeably American, as is always the case with books featuring emergency vehicles, but will still appeal greatly to little vehicle lovers, despite things looking a little different. Children will enjoy finding the letter hidden within the picture as well as other things that start with that letter. The illustrations are crisp, bold and easy on the eye. This is a fun book for those developing visual letter awareness and initial sound knowledge.
Nicole Nelson

Max Champion and the great race car robbery by Alexander McCall Smith

cover image

Ill. by Kate Hindley. Bloomsbury Children's Books, 2018. ISBN 9781408886137
(Age: 6-8) Recommended. Themes: Motor car racing. Criminals. Values. Good versus evil. When Max discovers that his grandfather was the inventor of the Champion motor cars he is stunned to discover that the greedy Mr Grabber had stolen his ideas and his car, Arabella, many years ago. Max decides to try and find a way to get back what his grandfather had lost.
Even though the Champions are poor they are very happy and always honest. Grandfather Gus is philosophical about the loss of his inventions, his mother works hard at her sandwich making business and Max mows lawns to help out. When his mother has to make a mountain of sandwiches for Mr Grabber, Max helps out and it is in the Grabber's mansion that Max uncovers some of the secrets that the Grabbers have been keeping.
This is feel good story of the poor but honest Champion family overcoming the rich and dishonest Grabber family, as Max manages to overcome all the difficulties he faces, and in a wild car race, finally wins out. Kate Hindley's illustrations bring the story to life and add an element of humour that children will delight in.
Permeating the story are the values of decency and honesty, working hard doing the right thing. Grandfather Gus has some very pertinent advice to give Gus amidst the excitement of his hiding from the villains, a thrilling car chase and winning out in the end.
This would make a great read aloud story and give rise to much discussion when values are being examined in the classroom.
Pat Pledger

Let me lie by Clare Mackintosh

cover image

Hachette, 2018. ISBN 9780751564877
(Age: Adult - Older adolescent) Themes: Mystery and suspense. Suicide. Grief. The dedication at the start of the narrative positions us perfectly to be led into a complex story of love, loyalty and betrayal, with Clare Mackintosh's choice of Benjamin Franklin's wise words to precede the narrative: "Three may keep a secret if two of them are dead". Indeed the use of "lie" in the title of the book itself is enigmatic, as we begin to realize what has happened.
Single mother, Anna, has an eight-week old child, Ella, with her partner, Mark, the psychologist she had been seeing since the disastrous disappearance of her parents, in what appears to have been separate suicides. Prior to the opening of the narrative, we learn, Anna's parents appeared to have run a successful car sales business for many years, apparently making money and in a successful personal relationship. However, the manner of their deaths, apparently suicide, and the things that Anna begins to discover suggest that all was indeed not well. This is where Murray, the retired policeman who is fascinated by the mystery, decides to investigate privately, both to help Anna, who is dismayed, afraid and angry, and to answer the questions that puzzle him.
Apart from the obvious lack of care of their daughter, having been somewhat venomous and not particularly loving parents, Anna had thought her life to be predictable and normal. She discovers, gradually, that all had not been well, that her parents had cared little for her and for each other, and she has been devastated by the lies that had filled her life and the dreadful events that appear to have occurred.
This book is imbued with a sense of decency, in how we should treat one another, how we should respond to tragedy, how indeed we should live in today's complex and often difficult world by caring for, and recognizing, the humanity and goodness of others. Tense, disturbing and at times shocking, this new novel tells a good story and leaves us understanding the terrible nature of some people, and of the hidden secrets and venom of some people's lives. Mackintosh elicits strong emotions in the reader as we begin to understand what others find the strength to do, not only to survive, but to approach life with love, hope, loyalty and respect so that they, and we, can live justly, if we are lucky, in this sometimes very daunting and dark world.
This book is suitable for adults and older adolescents, as it does deal with admirable and honourable attributes of humanity, tainted by the presence of betrayal, cruelty and violence.
Elizabeth Bondar

Tropical Terry by Jarvis

cover image

Walker Books, 2018. ISBN 9781406378627
(Ages: 3-6) Themes: Fish, Appearance. Coral Reef City is filled with some of the most colourful and fabulous fish of the ocean. A flurry of action words ("dashing, flashing, swirled") echo the movement of the sea seen in the illustrations, which feature minimal background detail comprised of white line drawings and speckled shades of matte blue, making the fish and colourful coral stand out. All of the pages are double page spreads to give the full panoramic experience of the sea. Poor Terry . . . in the midst of such a vibrant world he is plain blue and a very average fishy shape. He does have two great friends, Cilla the crab and Steve the sea snail, but as much as he loves playing with them (he is really good at hide-a-fish), he longs to be part of the tropical fish crew (they call him "Terry the DULL fish" and are definitely not interested in his silly games). After fancying himself up with colourful bits and bobs, Terry is finally able to join the popular gang, but when they run into a spot of bother, it's Terry's hiding skills that save the day. After this Terry realises that standing out isn't always great and starts to take pride in what makes him unique and special. The illustrations are beautiful but as a whole the book is let down a little by the text which lacks suspense and drama, especially when read aloud. In addition, while the story attempts to show that brains are superior to beauty it doesn't do this in a way that will be obvious to a very young audience.
Nicole Nelson

I Love You Dino-Daddy by Mark Sperring

cover image

Ill. by Sam Lloyd. Bloomsbury, 2018. ISBN 9781408893449
(Ages: 3-6) Themes: Fathers, Rhyming book. As a republication of a 2015 title, initially published as "Dino-Daddy", this puffy hardcover book has a shiny foil title that somehow makes it seem cheap at first glance. However, on opening it contains first-rate illustrations (the cover illustration is overshadowed by the glittery text and stars) and a rather lovely rhyming text. The dinosaur family are a beautiful vibrant green with rich facial expressions and oodles of energy. The pictures are imbued with a sense of fun, chaos and craziness that many kids will identify with as how it feels to hang out with dad. Hands-on, rough and tumble play, silly magic tricks and jokes on dad when he falls asleep on the couch are all accounted for. This is gender stereotypical, with dad being the fun, slightly irresponsible parent, but entertaining nonetheless (and you could always swap Daddy for Mummy when reading). The simple, rhyming text reads aloud well ("And though he has a list of jobs he has to dino-do, he always seems to find the time to play a game . . . or two!") and the humorous illustrations do a lot of the talking. A great Father's Day gift or read aloud that celebrates time spent together.
Nicole Nelson

What will I do when I grow up? by Margherita Borin

cover image

Berbay Publishing, 2018. ISBN 9780994384157
What will I do when I grow up by Margherita Borin is a picture book that as the title suggests, discusses a variety of careers people can do when they grow up. It centres around the high street of a town (or the Main Street as we know it in Australia) and focusses on a Chef, Builder, Scientist, Teacher and an Artist.
Each vocation is explained in a simple way, in respect to what the person may do, what instruments or equipment they may use and other things that may be involved with the job. Each section also ends with the question 'Would you like to be a... when you grow up" leaving it open for discussion with the reader.
Each of the jobs also has multiple pages of illustrations showing areas within the workplace and the actual equipment that may be used. For example - the chef section shows a kitchen, chef's uniform, utensils (knives, pots and pans, scales, blenders, mixers and graters to name a few), and a whole page of raw and cooked ingredients. The builder shows a work site, machinery and building equipment.
When reading this with my kids it was a good tool to talk about what they knew about these jobs and if they liked any of them. We also spent a lot of time looking at all the different pictures, naming them and how they can be used. Obviously there are a lot more jobs in the world than these 5 but it is a good introduction to the idea of a career and also an understanding of what adults do and who is behind many of the things we love i.e. How was our house built? Who cooks our dinner at a restaurant? How can we cure diseases and learn about the world? Who will we meet at school? We give it 3.5 out of 5.
Lauren Fountain