Reviews

The Land of Roar by Jenny McLachlan

cover image

Egmont, 2019. ISBN: 9781405293679.
(Age: 8-12) Recommended. Themes: Fantasy, Imaginary lands, Adventure, Magical Creatures, Good vs Evil, Twins. Rose and Arthur are twins who have spent holiday time with their grandad. As young children they played in Grandad's attic and created a mythical land where they were the heroes of imaginative battles and adventures. Now back at Grandad's home as eleven year olds, Rose and Arthur are not quite the connected twins that they used to be. Rose is only interested in her mobile phone and impressing the older girl next door whereas Arthur is keen to relive their childhood adventures in the attic. Rose treats Arthur disdainfully and Arthur keeps on hoping Rose will become the adventurous and fun sister she once was.
Grandad decides that this year he will give the children the attic as their own space but they will need to tidy it up and throw things out. While clearing things out, Arthur finds two important childhood memories of the Land of Roar which he cannot quite believe are true - an old hand drawn map and a sign saying "Enter here for the land of roar". While Grandad is helping Arthur he disappears into the Land of Roar through a rolled up bed mattress. This is where the twin's amazing journey begins. Arthur follows and meets all manner of magical creatures in his search for his missing grandfather. Rose eventually joins him and with their friend, Win, they must fight the evil Crowky in order to save their grandad.
The author has used every fragment of her imagination to create an exciting adventure where anything and everything is possible - magic roads, magic tunnels, stuffed scarecrows that fight, Lost Girls, dragons, mermaids, Prosecco the wooden horse from the attic and so much more. Young readers will enjoy the action and tension throughout the book as well as the clever illustrations to support the story. Throughout the whole story, Arthur is never quite sure if the Land of Roar is real or something he and Rose made up. Grandad tells him it is real in his imagination and "I wonder if every child has a world like this only not everyone is lucky enough to find it."
Kathryn Beilby

The Grace Year by Kim Liggett

cover image

Del Ray, 2019. ISBN: Del Ray, 2019. ISBN: 9781529100594. 404 pg., paperback.
No one speaks of the Grace Year. Little is known about what goes on during it, but every girl in the county knows one thing is certain. It will change them, if they survive it that is. The Grace Year by Kim Liggett is a feminist thriller centered on Tierney James, who lives in a village where all the girls are banished to the outskirts at sixteen for the entire year. To brave the wilderness and expel their magic is what they are told but really, they must also brave each other. Trust no one, not even yourself.
The Grace Year kept me grabbing the book wanting more and more whenever I had the chance. Kim wrote of such compelling characters that had such complex feelings and compulsions of their own that I wasn't able to tell what was going to happen next. Kim also described Tierney James well: she is a strong minded, logical yet rebellious girl coming into her womanhood and after following the rules of the county for all of her life she still finds it hard to break free from it all, to finally be free of what she has been told is expected of her. Going against what has been told of her, going against the men who control her life, even going against the other women around her, Tierney faces it all with as much strength as she can muster. The question is: Will it be enough?
Kayla Raphael. 404 pg., paperback.
No one speaks of the Grace Year. Little is known about what goes on during it, but every girl in the county knows one thing is certain. It will change them, if they survive it that is. The Grace Year by Kim Liggett is a feminist thriller centered on Tierney James, who lives in a village where all the girls are banished to the outskirts at sixteen for the entire year. To brave the wilderness and expel their magic is what they are told but really, they must also brave each other. Trust no one, not even yourself.
The Grace Year kept me grabbing the book wanting more and more whenever I had the chance. Kim wrote of such compelling characters that had such complex feelings and compulsions of their own that I wasn't able to tell what was going to happen next. Kim also described Tierney James well: she is a strong minded, logical yet rebellious girl coming into her womanhood and after following the rules of the county for all of her life she still finds it hard to break free from it all, to finally be free of what she has been told is expected of her. Going against what has been told of her, going against the men who control her life, even going against the other women around her, Tierney faces it all with as much strength as she can muster. The question is: Will it be enough?
Kayla Raphael

Rainbow Magic: Camilla the Christmas Present Fairy by Daisy Meadows

cover image

Orchard Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781408352465. 155pp., pbk.
Best friends Kirsty and Rachel are very excited to give each other their Christmas presents! But when Jack Frost steals Camilla the Christmas Present Fairy's magical objects, the magic of giving is in danger. Can the girls help get Camilla's items back and save Christmas for both the human and fairy worlds?
The Rainbow Fairies have been delighting young girls who are newly independent readers since 2003 with 254 fairies published and 11 yet to come. The series follows the lives of Kirsty Tate and Rachel Walker and their magical adventures with their fairy friends, Queen Titania, Queen of the fairies, King Oberon, King of the fairies and Jack Frost, who is the enemy of the fairies and his servants, the Goblins. With all the elements of fantasy that young girls love, the series has remained popular for 16 years so if you have someone ready to make the transition to novels this could be the one to start them. This new release features three stories, each with short chapters and illustrations to support the reader and with so many others in the series to move on to, it is perfect for managing this new step of the reading journey. There is also an online site so that there is much more to explore and engage in to enrich their experience, as well as suggestions for other series that will broaden their reading horizons.
Barbara Braxton

Some places more than others by Renee Watson

cover image

Bloomsbury Children's Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781526613684.
(Ages 8-12). Highly recommended. Themes: Family relationships, Fathers, Daughters, African American people, New York city. New York city can be a wonderful, busy place and for Amara it's the only place she wants to be for her twelfth birthday. She is eager to go with her father to Harlem to meet his estranged father and his other family and get to know the place where her father grew up. Feeling a little unsettled by the fact that her mother is finally having another child and questioning her strange relationship with her mother, Amara feels she will understand so much more about herself and her family if she can get to know more about their history in New York. Her father makes it clear that this is a work trip for him, and Amara finds it hard to accept that this is the reason he is avoiding her Grandpa Earl so much when they get there. Amara puts herself in danger in a large confusing city as she acts out when she gets frustrated with her cousins' attitude towards her and the fact that her father doesn't seem to want to spend any time with her in New York.
The trip for Amara is enlightening in lots of ways as she learns more about her father's childhood and how Grandpa Earl now realizes the mistakes he made when his son was a boy and is trying to make amends. Her grandpa tells her things about her father that bring them closer together and ultimately heals the rifts that seemed so insurmountable at the beginning of her journey. She also has a school history project to complete. The author includes information about the Suitcase Project that Amara's teacher sets them which is designed to get the children to research more about their families. It provides the perfect vehicle for Amara to fulfill her mother's wishes to get her father and Grandpa talking and the information included at the end of the book will provide classroom teachers with a great resource to use after reading this book.
This is a touching, thought provoking story with well-drawn, engaging characters that will make a big impact on the reader. It is about how exploring the places from our past can help us understand who we are and how our family effects our lives.
Gabrielle Anderson

Yinti Desert Cowboy by Pat Lowe and Jimmy Pike

cover image

Magabala Books, 2019 (c2000). ISBN: 9781925936933.
Recommended. Themes: Aboriginal life; Station life and work. The Yinti stories follow young Aboriginal lad, Yinti, as he grows, lives and works in North West Australia. In the third book in the series, Yinti has begun work as a station-hand on one of the cattle stations out of Derby, in Western Australia. Demonstrating great skills and capacity to learn quickly, he puts his considerable talents to work as a 'cowboy', wrangling cattle and riding horses. A later stint on a sheep station develops his station skills further. Aboriginal life changes as most of his community head to work with the kartiya (white people) who are running the stations, and their traditional skills are adapted to a new way of life. With the advent of wages, the provision of kartiya food supplies, and with risks of the stockman life sometimes requiring medical treatment as a consequence of injury, there are many changes in Yinti's life.
The insights into Aboriginal life after moving from a purely traditional hunting lifestyle are revealed in this simple collection of anecdotal stories, based on Jimmy Pike's own experience. The book is a great insight into aboriginal ingenuity and capacity, and is worth reading. Although there are references to historical atrocities involving aboriginal people, this is handled very simply and yet powerfully for a young audience.
Having now read all three of Yinti's stories, I am impressed at the power of these stories to create cultural understanding. They are certainly worth sharing with a young audience and would make great read-aloud stories. Note, by the end of this, the third book in the series, Yinti is exploring 'adult life' and a romance with a married girl at the back of the station wood-pile is obliquely hinted at, rather than explained in detail. This book is perhaps more suited to a slightly older reader as a consequence.
Carolyn Hull

Emily Brown and Father Christmas by Cressida Cowell and Neal Layton

cover image

Hodder Children's, 2019. ISBN: 9781444942002. 32pp., pbk.
It's Christmas Eve and Emily Brown and Stanley have hung up their Christmas stockings and are snuggled up in bed reading when they hear "Ho Ho Help" coming from outside their window. It is Father Christmas and despite having the latest climbing equipment, he is swinging precariously from a rope and needs rescuing. Emily suggests that dropping down the chimney might be better because "Sometimes the old ways are the best ways." But Father Christmas is determined to embrace the new ways even though it gets him into strife all night. Will the children around the world get their gifts on Christmas morning or will they all be disappointed?
This is a very funny story that will appeal to both the reader and listener alike. With its refrain of "Sometimes the old ways are the best ways" it marries the magical side of Christmas deliveries that we are familiar with, with the idiosyncrasies that we have all experienced with modern technology. This is a Christmas story that has some substance to it with a determined, credible main character who will resonate with many and a storyline that will linger, particularly when our technology next plays up and we are wishing for some traditional Father Christmas magic.
Barbara Braxton

Oscar the Hungry Unicorn eats Christmas by Lou Carter

cover image

Illus. by Nikki Dyson. Orchard, 2019. ISBN: 9781408355824. 32pp., pbk.
Oscar the unicorn is always hungry and on Christmas Eve he is eating his way through the palace Christmas preparations. The stockings, the tree the presents . . . But the trouble really starts when he eats the reindeer food meaning the reindeer no longer have their magic power to fly. How will Santa deliver the presents?
This is a bright captivating tale that will enchant our youngest readers as they continue the Christmas Countdown to that special night. There is lots of humorous detail in the pictures, particularly the one focusing on Christmas morning and this is likely to be one that is requested again and again.
Barbara Braxton

The Princess Rules by Philippa Gregory

cover image

Illus. by Chris Chatterton. HarperCollins, 2019. ISBN: 9780008339791. 256p.
(Age: 7+) Recommended. Three stories by award winning author Philippa Gregory will be grabbed by readers who enjoy having their fairy tales turned upside down. Those who love adventure and humour too, will delight in the three tales in this book, 'Princess Florizella', 'Princess Florizella and the Wolves' and 'Princess Florizella and the Giant'. Princess Florizella is not your classic fairy tale princess. She does not abide by the Princess Rules (eat little, dress beautifully and have glorious hair) but is adventurous and happy to spend lots of time riding her horse Jellybean and working in the Palace office.
When Prince Bennett invites all the princesses to come to his kingdom so he could choose one to marry, she decides to go to see her friends and enjoy the party. She is not ready to marry.
First dedicated to her daughter, the stories have been presented once again, this time dedicated to her grandchildren. They have not lost their appeal and young readers will have a lot of fun following the antics of Princess Florizella as she rescues Prince Bennett, encounters a wolf pack and a giant. The illustrations by Chris Chatterton are full of amusing details and give the reader a feeling for the personality of Princess Florizella, her parents and Prince Bennett.
This is a perfect book for the newly confident reader who wants to embark on a book that is longer and more complex that the short junior novel, but which is divided up into three stories so is not as daunting as a longer novel could prove to be.
Pat Pledger

Rescue by David Long

cover image

Illus. by Kerry Hyndman. Faber and Faber, 2019. ISBN: 9780571346325. hbk. 192p.
(Age: 9+) A book for fans of heroic deeds, Rescue will fascinate readers who enjoy reading about the bravery of real people. Subtitled Daring missions from on, under and above the earth, there are 28 stories of incredible feats by people all around the world, ranging from the rescue of a young child trapped in a well, to diving into a lake to pull people out of submerged bus, Sully's magnificent landing of an aeroplane in the Hudson River and a 9 year old boy rescuing his classmates after an earthquake.
Each story is relatively short (5 or 6 pages long) and illustrated with complementary coloured drawings, so it is ideal for the reader who likes to have short bursts of reading with the opportunity to come back again if individual stories appeal. And there is plenty of information that is sure to grab the reader's attention.
I particularly enjoyed the story of 'Buster' Cain who rescued people during the London Blitz and 'The Seebies: saving a family teetering on the edge', had me holding my breath as a mother and her two children were rescued from a car, hanging from a bridge.
There is a contents page with titles that give a good indication of what the story might be about, and each story has captions that grab the reader's attention and make you want to read on.
The epilogue states that 'you don't need superpowers or a mask and cape to be a real-life hero,' and this book is sure to inspire young readers with its stories of gallantry and heroism.
Pat Pledger

Twelve days of kindness by Cori Brooke and Fiona Burrows

cover image

New Frontier, 2019. ISBN: 9781925594751. 32pp., hbk.
Nabila is the new girl in school and like many new kids, she's finding it hard to fit in with the established crew, particularly when she looks different to them and eats her strange lunches alone. But Holly comes to her rescue as their common love for soccer takes over. But when both Holly and Nabila are picked for the school team, there is still disunity and the two girls realise if they are to come together to play well, they need a plan . . .
A search for "Twelve Days of Kindness" on the Internet brings up a number of projects and resources, mostly connected to Christmas but this is something that could be developed by a group or an individual at any time to promote kindness, compassion, empathy and build something harmonious. Some schools like to take students on camp in the early days of Term 1 to build bonds for a successful year, but if this is not viable, organising something like Twelve Days of Kindness could be an alternative. Having students directly involved by having them articulate those things they don't like and identifying how such behaviour can be changed and the environment they would like to be in gives ownership and helps them understand the power to change is in their hands. Promoting empathy activities rather than always focusing on the 'don'ts' of bullying can be a new approach that has an impact by making it personal. Again, the solution is theirs to decide and implement.
Author of the CBCA shortlisted All I Want for Christmas is Rain, (as appropriate now as it was in 2016) Brooke has again delivered a story that promotes thought and inspires action. Teacher's notes are available.
Barbara Braxton

Harry Potter and the goblet of fire by J.K. Rowling

cover image

Illus. by Jim Kay. Harry Potter, book 4. Bloomsbury, 2019. ISBN: 9781408845677. hbk.
(Age: 8+) Highly recommended. Readers will need no introduction to the wonderful books by J.K. Rowling and fans and collectors will certainly want to keep this fabulous illustrated version of the fourth book in the series, Harry Potter and the goblet of fire.
Jim Kay's illustrations open up a new world for readers which will take them past the film images and let their imaginations work overtime. Starting with the fabulous wrap around jacket featuring a tiny Harry Potter battling an enormous beast, opening onto end papers showing a strange and fascinating octopus-like creature and then continuing with brightly coloured illustrations for lighter moments in the book, and dark, intriguing pictures for darker events, readers are in for a treat.
This is certainly a book for fans and for collectors and would make a wonderful gift. I also think that the illustrated editions (Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone by J.K. Rowling has also been reviewed) would tantalise even the most reluctant of readers
Pat Pledger

Finding Chika by Mitch Albom

cover image

Hachette, 2019. ISBN: 9780751571936.
(Age: Older adolescents - Adult) Highly recommended. A dark mass on her brain - this is what the MRI showed, following the examination of little Chika by a neurologist, and there was no one in Haiti who could help her. Brought to America by author Mitch Albom, the operator of the orphanage in Haiti where he met Chika, the diagnosis was a brain tumour with the survival rate of zero. Albom and his wife Janine had to make to a decision - to take her back to Haiti to spend the last few months of her life . . . or to fight it. They decide to fight - because Chika has always been a fighter. She was born just before the Haitian earthquake of 2010, and brought to the orphanage at the age of three; they know her as a cheeky fun-loving child with an indomitable spirit.
The book becomes a love letter to the little girl who captured their hearts. Albom has written it as if he were talking to her still. With each chapter he describes the different ways she changed their lives; the laughter, the games, the hugs, and then sadly the farewell. Every reader will love Chika as the Alboms did, and no doubt every reader will also shed tears at the heart-breaking conclusion. At the age of seven, she had to give up the fight. But Chika lives on in the joy she brought to a family and the renewed discovery of love and caring for others.
This is a sad but beautiful story, and a reminder to us all to cherish the people in our lives, and to take time out to appreciate what life offers us. Themes: Love, Grief, Childhood cancer.
Helen Eddy

Madame Badobedah by Sophie Dahl

cover image

Illus. by Lauren O'Hara. Walker Books, 2019. ISBN: 9781406384406. hbk.
(Ages 6-8). Recommended. Themes: Hotels, Girls, Villains, Friendship, Trust. Madame Badobedah is a rather enchanting story told by Mabel who lives in a bed and breakfast called "The Mermaid Hotel". The hotel, which is managed by her parents, is next to the beach. Mable is an only child who enjoys interacting with the guests as they come and go. She calls herself an adventurer and spends many hours barefoot exploring her surroundings but turns into a spy when the newest guest arrives. The mysterious Madame Badobedah (rhymes with oooh la la), who is very gruff and unfriendly, has a mountain of very peculiar luggage and many pets. Mabel decides she must be a super villain and sets about studying her subject to uncover all her secrets. Mabel shows how observant she is as she reports what she knows about the adults around her and everything her new subject tells her during her visits with the Madame.
The story uncovers the facts about the Madame slowly, drawing more and more out with each small visit Mabel makes to this strange yet intriguing person. This makes the story enjoyable and keeps the reader interested. A friendship develops between Mabel and the very lonely Irena through play and pretending games and the reader is given a lovely insight into the special relationship that can exist between the young and the very old. Perhaps Dahl making connections to when her grandfather used her as the inspiration for his book the BFG.
Parents and teachers could use this story to discuss the dangers of judging people from first impressions and the wide variety of friendships that work between many different people. The illustrations are quite charming and whimsical and compliment the story very well. However, I am not sure who this book is aimed at; it would be a great first novel for younger children but is presented as rather a long picture book format. Read over three sittings using the three parts as a natural break is probably the best way to introduce this story to the younger children.
Gabrielle Anderson

Hey Grandude! by Paul McCartney

cover image

Illus. by Kathryn Durst. Penguin Random House, 2019. ISBN: 9780241375655. hbk.
(Ages 4-8) Themes: Grandparents, Imagination, Magic, Adventure. This book tells a charming story of four children who, while visiting their Grandad (or Grandude), brighten their drizzly, cold day by going on some exciting adventures. Using a magic compass and some postcards, Grandude says the magic words and they are transported to a variety of exotic locations, including a beach, the wild west and a peaceful Alpine scene. At each location something goes wrong and they need to be whisked away to safety. Grandude is always there ready and able to perform the rescue just in time. The magic words used by Grandude form an enjoyable opportunity for children to chant with the reader as they are repeated for each scene.
The story is enjoyable but not fantastic. The children I read it to like the idea of the story, but it is not one that will be a favourite for years to come. It seemed a little disjointed and the side jokes could have been left out producing a slicker read. Less is more. The story finishes with the magic that every parent wishes for; the children in bed and asleep without the rigorous bedtime routine. Now that's magic!
The illustrations are appropriate and colourful with plenty to look at for the audience if read aloud. Explanations of what a postcard and a compass is could form an entertaining discussion at Junior primary level in schools.
Gabrielle Anderson

The Fountains of Silence by Ruta Sepetys

cover image

Penguin, 2019. ISBN: 9780241422236.
(Age: Older adolescents and adults) Highly recommended. This is a stunning novel that tells a narrative through short chapters featuring many quotations from real people of the historical time and telling the story of real and imaginary characters, both American and Spanish, who lived in that time. The narrative features two eras, the first and longest beginning in 1957 and set only in Spain, the second much shorter and set in Dallas, Texas in 1975, and Madrid, Spain in 1976.
While most chapters are very short, the narrative is clearly revealed both through the inclusion of quotations, at the start of many chapters, from American newspapers and statements about Spain and Spanish issues. Thus we feel deeply connected and drawn into the exposition of the reality of the communication between America and Spain. The plot line is deeply embedded in the world of the Diplomatic corps. Similarly, the interaction between the business section of both countries, relating both particularly and directly to oil, and the interaction between the Americans who resided in Spain and the Spanish who were part of their world, is an intrinsic part of this story. We are drawn into this world through the reality of many extracts from official documents.
In this narrative, there is a sense of both an historical document enabling a development of our understanding and our consciousness of the reality of life in the country of Spain during this time, and of the reality of that world for the people who lived in that era. The dark secrets that underlie this narrative relate to Franco's dominating Presidency and that of the compliance of the leaders of the Catholic Church and its acceptable dominance in Franco's world, revealing some details that are both surprising and some that are deeply unsettling.
This novel would be particularly appropriate for older adolescent readers and adults, and is indeed an inspiring and challenging novel of events and principles observed during one of the unsettling periods in history.
Elizabeth Bondar