We're stuck by Sue deGennaro
Scholastic, 2019. ISBN: 9781760663476.
(Age: 4+) Highly recommended. Themes: Elevators, Friendship, City
life. With a tongue in cheek swipe at the unfriendly attitude of
people when getting into a lift in a city apartment, Sue deGennaro
highlights the isolation that many city dwellers create. Separated
from each other, rarely acknowledging another's existence, the
animals living in this apartment only needed a small prod to
communicate with each other.
A wonderful double page opens before the reader, making them turn
the book on its side so they can see the apartment house in its
entirety and the animals that live on each floor getting ready to
leave for work. Readers will have fun looking closely at the animals
to see what each wears and what work each does, so musing about
where they are going. DeGennaro's illustrations are enticing with
her pen and ink techniques, giving a humanity to the animals which
all readers will recognise; the large tuba player, the very busy
lion looking at his watch, the shy turtle sliding into the corner of
the lift, the very round hippo chef, the tall giraffe with a ladder!
and so on. Each is polite but stays guardedly aloof from the others
in the lift.
But something happens to bring them all together. The lift breaks
down and is stuck.
Turtle mentions that it is his birthday so without saying too many
words, the animals look into their various bags to find things to
help him celebrate his special day. Readers will be delighted and
amused seeing what each animal can design out of something very
simple - Crocodile inflates her rubber gloves, Hippo uses the
newspaper to make paper hats, Pelican finds a cake in his bag, and
they all sing out surprise to Turtle. Hippo helps Giraffe with her
allergies, Whale tells everyone she is a hairdresser and cuts lion's
mane, and they all settle down to chat and eat cake. When their
rescuers arrive, no rescuing is needed, and the firemen are invited
in for a cup of tea.
A delightful story well told will have children begging it to be
read again. Layers of understanding about life in a city, isolation
and lack of communication will not go unnoticed by the readers, as
they see that it only needs a small trigger for people to break down
the barriers. Readers will love to contemplate the next steps for
the residents of apartment block 24, now that their lives have
changed so completely.
Fran Knight