Alphonse, that is not ok to do by Daisy Hirst
Walker Books, 2016. ISBN 9781406354317
(Age: 4+) Recommended. Families. Siblings. When Alphonse eats
Natalie's book she is cross with him. He offers to mend her book,
but she puts her fingers in her ears so she cannot hear him. They
had been good friends, doing a lot of things together, naming birds
they see out of the window, hearing stories, bouncing things off the
bunk beds and making things together. So Alphonse is upset. Natalie
goes to have a bath by herself, but while there she hears enormous
noises. A tornado, screaming beasts and thousands of glass peas
falling down from the sky seem to be happening outside the room. She
becomes afraid for her brother and calls out to him, wrapping
herself in a towel to go and investigate. She opens the door to find
an appalling mess and he explains how the room came to be so untidy.
All Natalie can think about is her brother and keenly asks if he is
alright.
This is a charming tale of siblings not seeing eye to eye, of
falling out over a possession that the other has destroyed. But when
the possibility of something happening to her brother occurs she is
the first to investigate and all is put back to normal, with the two
getting along just as they did before. Children will love reading of
the trouble between them and be soothed by the resolution of their
problem. It is a situation many will have been in themselves, and so
seeing it resolved will give them the skills to draw some lessons
for their own situation. The block colour illustrations are
charming, with expressions given by the simplest of lines.
Fran Knight